Skip to content
Open
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
195 changes: 195 additions & 0 deletions integration-test-app/VERIFICATION_REPORT.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,195 @@
# Android Integration Test Framework - Verification Report

This document verifies the current Android integration test implementation against the requirements outlined in the Integration Testing Framework specification.

## Requirements Checklist

### 1. Lightweight Test App

**Status**: **COMPLETE**

- Minimal Android test app (`integration-test-app/`)
- Initializes mParticle SDK with WireMock endpoints
- Sends test events matching iOS integration test scenarios:
- User attributes (set, increment)
- Custom events
- Commerce events
- Session attributes
- Error logging
- Timed events
- Identity operations
- Configurable via credentials file (no hardcoded values)
- Single Activity design for simplicity

**Files**:

- `src/main/java/com/mparticle/integrationtest/IntegrationTestApplication.java`
- `src/main/java/com/mparticle/integrationtest/MainActivity.java`
- `src/main/AndroidManifest.xml`

### 2. WireMock Integration

**Status**: **COMPLETE**

- WireMock Docker setup documented
- Recording script (`record_android_tests.sh`) captures SDK requests
- Verification script checks WireMock for captured requests
- Mappings directory structure (`wiremock/mappings/android/`)
- Example mapping file provided
- Documentation for mapping format and dynamic fields

**Files**:

- `scripts/record_android_tests.sh`
- `scripts/common.sh` (WireMock functions)
- `wiremock/mappings/android/`

### ⚠️ 3. Automated Preprocessing

**Status**: **PARTIAL** - Needs Enhancement

**Current State**:

- Recording script saves mappings to `wiremock/mappings/android/recorded-mappings.json`
- ❌ No script to extract and normalize request bodies into separate jsonBody files
- ❌ No automated dynamic field replacement/preprocessing
- ❌ No baseline preparation script

**Gap**: Need preprocessing script to:

- Extract request bodies from recorded mappings
- Normalize dynamic fields (timestamps, IDs, etc.)
- Create clean baseline files for comparison
- Handle field templating/ignoring

**Recommendation**: Create `scripts/preprocess_recordings.sh` similar to iOS implementation.

### ⚠️ 4. Automated Verification

**Status**: **PARTIAL** - Needs Enhancement

**Current State**:

- Script rebuilds SDK (`build_sdk_and_app()`)
- Script launches emulator (`start_emulator()`)
- Script runs test app (`run_test_app()`)
- Script verifies requests exist in WireMock (`verify_requests()`)
- ❌ No baseline comparison/diff functionality
- ❌ No exit code 1 on mismatches (only checks if requests exist)
- ❌ No detailed diff reporting

**Gap**: Need enhanced verification to:

- Compare captured requests against baseline mappings
- Generate diffs for mismatches
- Fail with exit code 1 when baselines don't match
- Provide detailed mismatch reports

**Recommendation**: Enhance `verify_requests()` function to compare against baselines.

### ❌ 5. CI/CD Integration

**Status**: **MISSING**

**Current State**:

- ❌ No GitHub Actions workflow file
- ❌ No automated CI pipeline
- ❌ No artifact uploads (logs, test results)
- ❌ No integration with pull request checks

**Gap**: Need GitHub Actions workflow that:

- Runs on every build/pull request
- Executes full pipeline: rebuild → run → verify
- Uploads logs and artifacts
- Blocks merges on test failures

**Recommendation**: Create `.github/workflows/android-integration-tests.yml`

### 6. Documentation

**Status**: **COMPLETE** (with minor gaps)

- Main documentation (`INTEGRATION_TESTING.md`)
- Script documentation (`scripts/README.md`)
- WireMock mappings documentation (`wiremock/mappings/android/README.md`)
- README updated with integration testing section
- ⚠️ Could add more detail on baseline management workflow
- ⚠️ Could add CI/CD execution flow documentation

## Implementation Summary

### What's Working

1. **Test App**: Fully functional minimal Android app that sends events to WireMock
2. **Recording**: Script successfully records SDK requests to WireMock
3. **Basic Verification**: Script verifies that requests were captured
4. **Emulator Management**: Automated emulator startup and management
5. **Credentials**: Secure credential handling via file-based approach
6. **Documentation**: Comprehensive setup and usage documentation

### What's Missing

1. **Preprocessing Script**: Extract and normalize recorded requests
2. **Baseline Comparison**: Compare requests against stored baselines
3. **Diff Reporting**: Detailed mismatch reports
4. **CI/CD Integration**: GitHub Actions workflow
5. **Enhanced Verification**: Fail on baseline mismatches

## Recommendations

### High Priority

1. **Create Preprocessing Script** (`scripts/preprocess_recordings.sh`)
- Extract request bodies from recorded mappings
- Normalize dynamic fields (timestamps, IDs, etc.)
- Generate clean baseline files

2. **Enhance Verification** (`scripts/common.sh`)
- Add baseline comparison logic
- Generate diff reports
- Fail with exit code 1 on mismatches

3. **Add CI/CD Workflow** (`.github/workflows/android-integration-tests.yml`)
- Automated test execution
- Artifact uploads
- PR checks

### Medium Priority

4. **Improve Error Reporting**
- More detailed diff output
- Better error messages
- Test result summaries

5. **Add Baseline Management**
- Script to update baselines
- Baseline review process documentation
- Version control for baselines

### Low Priority

6. **Performance Optimization**
- Parallel test execution
- Caching strategies
- Tiered test suites (PR vs release)

## Next Steps

1. Implement preprocessing script for baseline extraction
2. Enhance verification with baseline comparison
3. Create GitHub Actions workflow
4. Test end-to-end workflow
5. Document baseline management process

## Compliance Score

**Overall**: 60% Complete

- Test App: 100%
- WireMock Integration: 100%
- ⚠️ Preprocessing: 30%
- ⚠️ Verification: 50%
- ❌ CI/CD: 0%
- Documentation: 85%
Loading
Loading