cleanBibImpact: Evaluating the impact of citation diversity statements #26
Description
Project info
Title:
cleanBibImpact: Evaluating the impact of citation diversity statements
Project leads:
- Kendra Oudyk (GitHub: koudyk | Mattermost: kendra.oudyk)
- Isil Bilgin (GitHub: complexbrains | Mattermost: isil)
Timezone:
We'll be working primarily in the 2PM-7PM UTC timeslot (Atlantis).
Project leads' time zones:
- Kendra: Montreal UTC-4
- Isil: London UTC+1
Description:
Gender imbalance is a big problem in academic research, and it is even reflected in our citation behavior. Our goal is to assess the 'impact' of the cleanBib tool, which was created to make researchers more aware of this problem. This tool can be used to assess the gender balance of authors in a reference list. Specifically, we want to find papers that cite the cleanBib code/paper/preprint, and see whether those citing papers have better gender balance in their reference lists than papers that do not.
In previous hackathons, we created this figure by manually collecting citation diversity data from papers with citation diversity statements. It shows the relative gender proportions in reference lists of papers with diversity statements (relative to the expected gender proportions).
Link to project:
GitHub repo
Running agenda
Mattermost handle:
kendra.oudyk
isil
Goals for the OHBM Brainhack
- 1. Manual inspection of citing papers' diversity statement
- 2. Assess whether citing papers have more diverse reference lists
- 3. Review our language around gender
Good first issues:
- Update manually-collected citation diversity data from citing papers for 2020 (part of Goal 1)
- Manually collect citation diversity data from citing papers for 2021 (part of Goal 1)
- Review our language around gender (Goal 3)
Skills:
If you're new to hackathons/coding (welcome!!), see if Project 1 or 3 would suit you 😊
| Goal | Skills needed |
|---|---|
| 1. Manual inspection of citing papers' diversity statement | - Google Scholar, - spreadsheets (pasting data; no calculations), - beginner Python (optional - opportunity to learn if you want to), - Git 0-1 (optional - opportunity to learn if you want to) |
| 2. Assess whether citing papers have more diverse reference lists | - Confirmed-expert Python, - working with APIs, - Git 2 |
| 3. Review language around gender | - Familiarity with gender theory, - Git 0-1 (optional - opportunity to learn if you want to) |
Chat channel:
hbm-cleanBibImpact
Video channel:
Jitsi video meeting room
Number of participants
This depends on participants' skill levels and interests, but we're aiming for no more than 8 so that we'll have time to make it a good experience for everyone.
Onboarding documents
Image for the OHBM brainhack website
https://raw.githubusercontent.com/koudyk/cleanBibImpact/master/reports/figures/relative_diversity__with_swarm__with_title.png
Twitter-size summary of your project pitch
Do papers with citation diversity statements have more gender-diverse citations?
Help us find the answer this week at the #ohbm2021
@brainhackorg hackathon in the cleanBibImpact project.We have issues that beginners and pros can work on - all are welcome.
Project snippet for the OHBM Brainhack website
title: "cleanBibImpact: Evaluating the impact of citation diversity statements"
image: https://raw.githubusercontent.com/koudyk/cleanBibImpact/master/reports/figures/relative_diversity__with_swarm__with_title.png
details: "Gender imbalance is a big problem in academic research, and it is even reflected in our citation behavior. Our goal is to assess the 'impact' of the [cleanBib](https://github.com/dalejn/cleanBib) tool, which was created to make researchers more aware of this problem. This tool can be used to assess the gender balance of authors in a reference list. Specifically, we want to find papers that cite the cleanBib [code](https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.3672109)/[paper](https://doi.org/10.1038/s41593-020-0658-y)/[preprint](https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.01.03.894378), and see whether those citing papers have better gender balance in their reference lists than papers that do not.
<br>More information <a href=https://github.com/ohbm/hackathon2021/issues/26>in this github issue</a>"
Project submission
Submission checklist
Once the issue is submitted, please check items in this list as you add under 'Additional project info'
Please include the following above (all required):
- Link to your project: could be a code repository, a shared document, etc. See here
- Include your Mattermost handle (i.e. your username). If you do not have an account, please sign up here.
- Goals for the OHBM Brainhack: describe what you want to achieve during this brainhack. See here.
- Flesh out at least 2 "good first issues": those are tasks that do not require any prior knowledge about your project, could be defined as issues in a GitHub repository, or in a shared document, cf here.
- Skills: list skills that would be particularly suitable for your project. We ask you to include at least one non-coding skill, cf. here.
- Chat channel: A link to a chat channel that will be used during the OHBM Brainhack. This can be an existing channel or a new one. We recommend using the Brainhack space on mattermost, cf. here.
- Provide an image of your project for the OHBM brainhack website
You can also include information about (all optional):
- Someone co-leading the project in the timeslot you have not selected to provide additional visibility.
- Number of participants, cf. here
- Twitter-size summary of your project pitch, cf. here
- Set up a kanban board on your repository to better divide the work and keep track of things, cf here
- Project snippet for the OHBM Brainhack website, cf. here
We would like to think about how you will credit and onboard new members to your project. We recommend reading references from this section. If you'd like to share your thoughts with future project participants, you can include information about (recommended):
- Specify how will you acknowledge contributions (e.g. listing members on a contributing page).
- Provide links to onboarding documents if you have some.
QMENTA has agreed to sponsor the event and provide computational resources through their platform.
- Get in touch with QMENTA through their Brain Innovation Hub Slack space, if you think your project would benefit from their support.